| YEAR | SCHOOL | PLAYER | YEAR | SCHOOL | PLAYER | |
| 1975 | SAVANNA | BRIAN HAYES | 1993 | LA QUINTA | JIM LIVERNOIS | |
| 1976 | NO. TORRANCE | 1994 | LOARA | ART ORTIZ | ||
| 1977 | TROY | LANCE BREWER | 1995 | CYPRESS | BOB BRITO | |
| 1978 | LOARA | 1996 | CYPRESS | BOB BRITO | ||
| 1979 | LOARA | COLIN MORISAKO | 1997 | MAGNOLIA | GREG YOUNG | |
| 1980 | SAVANNA | DAVE CASTILLO | 1998 | PARAMOUNT | SHAWN HABELITZ | |
| 1981 | LB POLY | 1999 | KATELLA | MIKE MARTINEZ | ||
| 1982 | JF KENNEDY | STEVE ISHII | 2000 | KATELLA | JON LORENZEN | |
| 1983 | CANYON | WAYNE GILLES | 2001 | TRABUCO HILLS | STEVE BOATRIGHT | |
| 1984 | LB POLY | JEFF TROTT | 2002 | KENNEDY | PATRICK CASSA | |
| 1985 | SAVANNA | 2003 | SANTA MARGARITA | JARED HUGHES | ||
| 1986 | FULLERTON | JEFF MIDDLEBROOKS | 2004 | DIAMOND BAR | TREVOR BARKLEY | |
| 1987 | WESTERN | MARK HOLIDAY | 2005 | TRABUCO HILLS | BOBBY TOMASCO | |
| 1988 | LA QUINTA | MIKE WILSON | 2006 | TRABUCO HILLS | STEVEN TEDESCO | |
| 1989 | LA QUINTA | JASON PARSONS | 2007 | LAKEWOOD | TREVOR COSTGIN | |
| 1990 | ANAHEIM | DANNY CASTRO | 2008 | MATER DEI | TYLER RAHMTULLA | |
| 1991 | KENNEDY | RICH LYON | 2009 | MISSION VIEJO | WADE KELLICK | |
| 1992 | DANA HILLS | TIM WOLTER | 2010 | CHAMINADE | BRANDO TESSAR | |
| 2011 | JSERRA | CLAY WILLIAMSON |